Go to Pampers WebsiteThinkBaby.co.uk
 Home » News > Newborn babyFriday 25 July 2008 | Help | Glossary  
Newsletter sign-up
Join ThinkBaby now
Join for FREE and use the forum, gallery and receive our newsletters.
why join?  
Join Pampers.co.uk
Essential reading from our sponsors
Splash About
Safe swimwear means stress-free holidays for parents and children!
Tomy
Tomy’s new Freestyle Carrier range
VOTE
As a new parent, where do you get your home safety advice from?
Midwife
Health visitor
Look it up online
Look it up in a book/magazine
Don't get enough advice
Forum Hot Threads
134649 Total Messages
TTC Gang Cont....
by Kia
mums due nov 08
by sunflower
due august 2008
by ameranne
it finally worked!!!
by Natty B and Bump
overweight and pregnant part 2
by ameranne
» Loads More Threads
Latest Reviews
924 Total Reviews
Tommee Tippee Nappy Wrapper
by shellifagan
icandy Pear
by inwell
icandy Apple Pushchair
by Fiddley
icandy Apple Pushchair
by Brelaw
icandy Cherry
by Angel100
Great Little Trading Company Bumbo
by Carmel Wilkinson
Britax Duo Plus Isofix
by LTC1972
» Loads More Reviews
 NEWBORN BABY 05 / 08 / 07
 

Breast or bottle, which really is best?

It's only a few decades ago that new mothers in the UK were positively discouraged from breastfeeding by many hospitals and maternity homes. How times change. Nowadays the medical establishment is pretty much unanimous that there's no doubt that being fed breast milk gets your baby off to the best start. Why? Because breast milk offers your new baby everything that he needs, and nothing that he doesn't need. Particularly important are the first days of colostrum which provide valuable antibodies and hormones to stimulate digestion. Not everyone is comfortable with the idea of breastfeeding however, and for one reason or another some women find that they can't breastfeed.

Ultimately the best way to feed your baby is the way that ensures he gets a proper feed. If you still haven't made you mind up how you'll feed your newborn here are the main advantages and disadvantages of each.

Breastfeeding

Advantages

  • Good for baby - Your breast milk is designed by nature to give your baby everything he needs and nothing that he doesn't need. Breastfeeding is the natural extension of the nutrition you provided for your baby in the womb and your milk changes according to your baby's needs. The colostrum of the first couple of days contains important antibodies to help your baby stave off infections
  • Protection - Breastfeeding doesn't only offer your baby protection against disease in the early days, there's also evidence that breastfed babies are less likely to develop any allergies that they are genetically prone to and less likely to develop infant illnesses. Breastfeeding may also reduce the likelihood of your baby developing childhood diseases
  • Bonding - There's nothing more intimate than breastfeeding for both mother and baby. Feeding offers valuable time of skin-to-skin and eye-to-eye contact: your baby will be comforted and reassured by the smell and touch of your own body, a body he's not yet aware of being physically separated from
  • Feel good - Breastfeeding prompts your body to release love hormones that make you feel happy and relaxed - though it may not feel like it at times when you're struggling to settle into a feed with your baby!
  • Convenient - There are both inconveniences and conveniences with breastfeeding, on the positive side you don't need to carry round an assortment of feeding accessories with you wherever you go, you've got all you need yourself
  • Reducing colic - Breastfed babies are likely to be less colicky as babies swallow less air when fed by breast
  • Returning to mum to shape - There's been a lot made breastfeeding helping mum get back into shape recently, and while it's not the magic answer to shedding all those pregnancy pounds, it is true that breastfeeding stimulates the uterus to shrink back to it's pre-pregnancy size more quickly
  • Contraceptive effect - To make sure that your body gets a rest after having a baby women who breastfeed regularly several times a day will have their periods return much later than women who don't breastfeed - usually after they wean their baby. Make sure you read up about contraception after birth before you rely entirely on this for contraception though

Disadvantages

  • Breast problems - Breastfeeding isn't necessarily problem-free, you may have trouble with sore or cracked nipples, engorged and painful breasts and mastitis. All of these are uncomfortable for the mother and mastitis will require treatment, but it's quite common and can be treated effectively
  • Dietary restrictions - As you are continuing as your baby's source of nutrition you have to be careful about your own nutrition and continue to avoid certain food and limit your intake of others, eg. alcohol and caffeine
  • Hormonal instability - Breastfeeding releases hormones that make you feel good, but the continuing fluctuation in hormones after pregnancy can also play havoc with your emotions
  • Inconvenience - While in some ways breastfeeding is incredibly convenient in that you can in large part dispense with hauling around bottles and sterilising equipment everywhere you go, it can be less convenient when you're not at home and trying to find a suitable quiet place to feed and some mums are less comfortable than others with breastfeeding in public. Breastfeeding may also make you feel a little trapped as your breasts are in frequent demand
  • Dads - Breastfeeding is obviously something that dad can't take part in and he may feel left out (though probably not at 3.30 in the morning when baby's demanding a feed), to compensate for this you can express milk with a breast pump so dad can bottle feed your baby while you get chance to be somewhere else for a change
  • Sex - Some mothers find that they have lower libido when breastfeeding and it may interfere with your sex life in other ways, for instance by changing the way you view your breasts

Bottle feeding

Advantages

  • Involving dad - If you decide to bottle feed you or your partner will be able to feed the baby without a supply of expressed milk
  • Convenience - If you're out and about with your baby it's generally easier to find a comfortable place for a feed, although this is changing all the time as breastfeeding becomes more common
  • Less discomfort - After the first few days when your milk comes in and engorges your breasts painfully your breasts will return to normal and you'll be spared the possible physical discomforts of pregnancy such as sore nipples and swollen breasts
  • Your breasts are your own - Some women feel uncomfortable with the idea of breastfeeding, even though it's completely natural, and they can't get past a reluctance to allow the role their breasts play to change and develop

Disadvantages

  • Health - Bottle feeding isn't bad for your baby, he will still get all the nutrients he needs from the specially -designed formula, but your baby will miss out on the extra benefits of breast milk, like the antibodies it contains
  • Equipment - You'll need to carry about the feeding paraphernalia with you wherever you go with your baby
  • Time- Sterilising bottles and mixing formula is more complicated than simply putting your baby to the breast, but if you're advance-planning is good it shouldn't take you too long to make up the feeds for the day

The ThinkBaby verdict

Breastfeeding offers a great start in life for your baby, and it makes sense to at least give it a go, but if it's not for you then don't berate yourself, the best way to feed is the way that results in a well-fed baby and a contented mum.


Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Discuss this article, 1 of 2 messages, read more:
Sam Tel 
Posted: 02/12/07 19:27:37 37
"Health - Bottle feeding isn't bad for your baby,..."

I'm sorry but it is. Breastfeeding is the biological norm, it is what nature intended. Therefore it does not have benefits, Formula - or Artificial Feeding, only has disadvantages.

Breastmilk has everything your baby needs. Formula is deficient in many ingredients.
Many of the added nutrients in formula are largely indigestable, meaning they aren't absorbed fully.

If you want any more information on this, read "Watch your Language" by Diane Wieseinger.
Read more...
Related articles:
Burping your baby
Some babies have no problem ridding themselves of that excess air after a feed and sound like a ship honking its arrival in harbour. Others take longer to get the hang of it.
Calcium and children
Calcium is important in building bone and muscle strength as your child grows, and into adulthood
Breastfeeding central
All the info and advice you need on breastfeeding
Getting started with breastfeeding
What you need to know to get on the right track
Study claims no link between IQ and breastfeeding
Despite the many other benefits of breastfeeding your baby, scientists believe breastmilk does not lead to a higher IQ.
Foods to avoid when breastfeeding
Although there is no longer a need to avoid some of the foods that can cause problems in pregnancy, there are still a few no-nos.
The Munchkin competition winner!
Find out who has won our user review competition!
Mixed feelings on breastfeeding
NUK have commissioned an interesting survey about new mother's experiences of the reality of breastfeeding.
Review: Munchkin Tri-flow feeding bottle
Groovy baby bottle where you change the flow of milk with a unique twist action on the neck ring
Nipple trouble
Breast is best, but it can be hard dealing with sore or cracked nipples in the easy days of feeding. We share some tips.
Supporting your partner in breastfeeding
You may not have breasts, but as a man you can still play an important role in smoothing the road for breastfeeding your baby
Breastfeeding - the real deal
Breastfeeding easy? One mum sets the record straight and tells us why the potential trials of breastfeeding are ultimately well worth it

Members Logon
Email:
Password:
forgot your
password?
Click to support ThinkBaby

 Send to friend | Join Now ^ Top of Page
About ThinkBaby
- About Us
- Privacy Policy
- Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to THINKBABY RSS news feed.
Contact Us
- Support
- Advertise with us
- FAQ
- Retailers: free site review
Magicalia Digital Publishing
Cycling
- BIKEmagic
- RoadCyclingUK
- SheCycles
- LondonCycleSport
- Visordown
- ProTourNews
Outdoors
- OUTDOORSmagic
- FISHINGmagic
- GOLFmagic
- TheMainSail
Lifestyle
- ThinkBaby
- Gardening.co.uk
- AVReview
- ThinkCamera
Hobbies
- ModelFlying
- MilitaryModelling
- ModelBoats
- GetWoodWorking

- Full Portfolio
© 1999-2008 Magicalia Ltd.